Single point, cantilever beam, S-shaped, column: a hardcore competition and selection guide for the four major structures of industrial weighing sensors

Nov 21, 2026 Leave a message

In the field of industrial weighing and force measurement, there is no "one size fits all" sensor. The accuracy drift and frequent damage that occur in many projects in the later stage have actually planted the seeds of trouble in the selection stage.

 

We often see that the purchase list only states "precision C3, range 500kg, stainless steel", but the supplier asks back, "Do you need single point, cantilever beam, S-shaped or column? "Many engineers are unable to answer.

 

The elastic structure of the sensor determines its stress mode, resistance to eccentric loads, and space occupation. Today, we will delve into the four most commonly used sensor structures in the industry and provide you with a hardcore selection guide.

 

一., The working principles and force models of the four classic structures

 

1.Single point type - the terminator of eccentric load

 

Force characteristics: usually rectangular, fixed at both ends, and subjected to force in the middle. Using a parallel beam structure, regardless of whether the load is applied to the center, edge, or corner of the table, the output signal is basically consistent.

 

Advantage: Natural ability to resist biased loads. Only one sensor is needed to support the entire countertop, eliminating the need for complex junction boxes and angle adjustment.

 

Applicable scenarios: electronic pricing scales, packaging scales, small platform scales (supported by a single sensor).

 

Limitations: The range is usually small (mostly between 3kg-1000kg), and the large tabletop is limited.

 

2. Cantilever beam/shear beam type - the backbone of the industrial sector

 

Force characteristics: One end is fixed, and the other end carries (cantilever structure). Strain gauges are attached to the neutral axis of the beam to mainly measure shear strain (double shear beams are more resistant to eccentric loads).

 

Advantages: Minimalist structure, low installation height, excellent lateral force resistance.

 

Applicable scenarios: tank leg weighing, weighing scales, belt scales, forklift scales. It is the most common and widely used structure in industrial manufacturing.

 

Limitations: Single end force, installation needs to ensure that the base is flat and must be matched with a limit mechanism to prevent lateral sliding.

 

3. S-type - a versatile hand that can be used for both tension and compression

 

Force characteristics: It has an S-shaped shape and is connected by threaded holes at both ends, which can withstand both tensile and compressive forces simultaneously.

 

Advantages: Dual directional measurement of tension and compression, extremely convenient installation, compact size.

 

Applicable scenarios: Hanging weighing of hook scales, batching scales, tensile testing machines, and hoppers.

 

Limitations: Weak ability to resist eccentric loads, the load must be strictly applied along the central axis, and lateral forces are strictly prohibited.

 

4. Column/Shake Column - Overloaded and Self Resetting King

 

Force characteristics: cylindrical elastic body, capable of withstanding vertical axial pressure. The high-end model is equipped with a "rocking column" structure, which allows the bearing capacity to tilt and automatically reset.

 

Advantages: Ultra high rigidity and resistance to large impacts, with a range of several hundred tons. The shaking column design can automatically solve lateral forces and thermal expansion and contraction.

 

Applicable scenarios: Large scale truck scales, track scales, heavy-duty storage tanks (over 100 tons).

 

Limitations: Large size, high cost, and the vast majority can only be used for compression (cannot be pulled).

 

二, Selection Decision Tree: How to Match Your Real Operating Conditions?

 

When selecting, please ask yourself three questions in sequence:

 

1.Are you under tension or pressure?

 

Tension (suspension) → Select S-type.

 

Compression (support) → Choose cantilever beam, column or single point type.

 

2.Is the load eccentric? (Place it randomly at the corners of the table)

 

Yes, and the tabletop is not large → menu style.

 

No, or there are multiple sensor supports → Select cantilever beam/column.

 

3.Is there a significant temperature difference or impact in the environment?

 

Large material tank with severe thermal expansion and contraction → Choose a shaking column module with automatic reset function.

 

High frequency dynamic sorting ->Select single point or special material cantilever beams with high stiffness and fast response.

 

三, Avoiding pitfalls: 3 selection errors that lead to sensors dying tragically

 

In after-sales data, besides electrical interference, the following three selection errors are the main reasons for sensor failure:

 

1.Blindly selecting range with "edge jamming"

 

some engineers have calculated the maximum weight of the equipment to be 10 tons, so they directly order a 10 ton sensor. But in practical operations, the dynamic impact force (overshoot) when a heavy object falls may be 1.5 or even 2 times the static weight. Correct practice: The rated capacity of the sensor should be greater than 1.2 to 1.5 times the maximum daily load (even 2 times when considering impact).

 

2.Replace shear beams with S-shaped supports

 

The two ends of the S-type sensor are threaded and can only withstand axial tension and compression naturally. If it is used as a bottom support, any slight lateral force or torsional moment will cause the elastic body to twist, resulting in not only reading drift but also easy detachment of internal strain gauges.

 

3.Neglecting the fatigue limit of materials

 

In vibration or high-frequency weighing scenarios (such as high-speed sorting scales), ordinary alloy steel may experience metal fatigue. At this point, sensors that have undergone millions of fatigue tests must be selected, or stainless steel/higher grade materials must be chosen. This is also why the source manufacturer's "20% increase in material life compared to ordinary" is so important.

 

四, From selection to implementation: Customization capability is the key closed loop

 

Many non-standard devices, such as special reaction vessels and lifting platforms, often cannot find standard sensors that perfectly match the size.

 

This requires suppliers not only to have a standard full range of products, but also to have strong OEM/ODM customization capabilities. Taking Shandong Leheng as an example, its team of 10+R&D engineers can complete the structural modification and confirmation of non-standard sensors within one week based on customer drawings for special installation spaces of customers in different industries around the world.

 

Behind this customized advantage, strict 100% full inspection is still indispensable. Because whether it is a single point or column type, even if the structural design is perfect, if the internal strain gauge pasting process is unstable and the four corner error is large when leaving the factory, on-site debugging is still a disaster. Only by ensuring that every sensor leaving the factory has extremely high consistency can customized solutions truly be implemented.

 

 

Send Inquiry

Send Inquiry